Close,Up,On,Fbi,Sign,On,Uniform,Of,The,Agent,
Ethics Complaint

LDAD Files Ethics Complaint against FBI Special Agent Hugh Raymond Evans

June 28, 2021

Oct 27, 2026

Editorial credit: Shuterstock

Lawyers Defending American Democracy, along with a group of prominent lawyers, has filed an ethics complaint with the Disciplinary Commission of the Alabama State Bar against Hugh Raymond Evans, a member of the Alabama bar who serves as a special agent of the Federal Bureau of Investigation.

The complaint concerns the sworn affidavit Mr. Evans submitted to a U.S. Magistrate Judge in January 2026 to obtain a search warrant for 2020 election records held by Fulton County, Georgia. The FBI executed the warrant on January 28, 2026, seizing more than 650 boxes of ballots and other election materials. The complaint alleges that the affidavit withheld from the court material information: that Georgia election authorities had already investigated and rejected the very allegations on which it relied – a critical fact that was not included in the affidavit.

The complaint alleges that:

  • Mr. Evans’s affidavit rested on five claimed “defects” in Fulton County’s handling of the 2020 election that were essentially the same allegations previously reviewed by the Georgia Secretary of State’s Investigations Division and the Georgia State Election Board.
  • Those Georgia authorities, in investigations concluded in 2022 and 2024, found the allegations unsubstantiated, “simply incorrect,” or immaterial to the accuracy of the election results. One concerned ballot images that Georgia law did not require counties to retain in 2020.
  • The affidavit did not disclose to the Magistrate Judge the existence of those investigations or their findings, presenting the allegations as credible when state authorities had concluded otherwise.

The complaint states that these omissions violated Alabama Rules of Professional Conduct 8.4(c), which prohibits conduct involving dishonesty, deceit, or misrepresentation, and 8.4(d), which prohibits conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice. Although Mr. Evans was acting as an FBI agent rather than as a lawyer, the Alabama rules apply to members of the bar whether or not the conduct occurs in the course of representing a client, and disciplinary authorities elsewhere have sanctioned lawyer-law enforcement officers for omitting material facts from sworn affidavits.

The complaint also describes the harm to the public from the seizure, which drew national attention after the involvement of Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard and President Trump, and from election denialism more broadly. Despite the FBI assigning some 260 analysts to examine the seized records, no further legal action has been taken in the more than eight months since the seizure. The complaint asks the Commission to investigate and impose appropriate discipline.

“A search warrant affidavit is a sworn statement to a judge, and a judge can only be as fair as the facts put in front of her. Telling a court only the half of the story that supports a search is not candor. Lawyers who hold a bar license carry that duty of honesty with them, whatever badge they wear,” said Jim Moliterno an LDAD volunteer and a principal author of the complaint.

Scott Harshbarger, the chair of LDAD’s board and a former two-term Attorney General, noted, “The seizure of a county’s election records by federal agents is an extraordinary step. When it rests on claims that state election officials had already investigated and rejected, and the court is never told so, public confidence in both our elections and our courts suffers. That conduct deserves a full investigation.”

doc-icon

ETHICS COMPLAINT

doc-icon

PRESS RELEASE

Stay Informed —

Be the first to know about LDAD news by following us on social media (LinkedIn, Instagram, Bluesky, and Facebook) and by signing up for our newsletter.

featured press